It was that time of year again, my phone’s upgrade was due and the question arose – do I stay Android?
I do love Android but was thinking about having a change (By the way, my previous phone was a Samsung Galaxy S). For me, every year when I get an upgrade and renew my contract the 18 month tie doesn’t seem long but boy … it is! This year it was between these two phones:
I was sat in the shop holding both these handsets; the Samsung Galaxy S 2 was thin, light and size friendly. The HTC Titan was thin, light and large – very large. It’s screen comes at a size of 4.7″ against the S2’s 4.3″ and despite it not being a SuperAMOLED it’s very bright (something that makes the Windows Phone 7’s (WP7) live tiles stand out amazingly).
If I hadn’t had the Galaxy S before I would hands down choose the S2 but, like I said, I wanted a change from the Android OS that is storming the market, but why? I’m not going to lie, I am a sucker for a good user interface. At first Android was amazingly quick and looked great with it’s endless customization but after time it became sluggish and at times I wanted to chuck it at a wall. WP7 on the other hand looks just as nice (especially their newest update ‘Mango’), it’s colorful tiles that change randomly revealing different information had me hooked and after a bit of research on the net found out that it integrates all your social networks meaning that you don’t have to open the horrid Facebook application at all – you can change your status, check your wall and post things right from the OS – the decision was swaying over to the Titan at this point.
But wait! Android’s new OS update was coming to the S2 very soon. ‘Ice Cream Sandwich’ is part of their sweet named firmware and looks and feels completely different to it’s counterparts, and all I wanted was a change so this pulled me back toward the Samsung. And then there is the dilemma of the App stores on both handsets. Android’s market is growing rapidly with the advantage of some awesome free apps where other platforms you have to pay i.e. Angry Birds and also a large selection of customization options too. WP7 on the other hand is smaller in comparison, with it being a new OS the store is in it’s infancy. The integration of Xbox Live though and the ability to see who is online, send messages, play games while earning achievements was very tempting – because who doesn’t want to raise that Gamer Score?
The problem for me was Android’s app store. With it having quite loose restrictions on what can get onto the shelves of it’s digital store there is a high proportion of poorly created apps, ones that work and play like an ancient toy. On my Galaxy S previously, the amount of stuff I downloaded and then forgetting to uninstall clogged up my phone making it as slow as a game of boules. This was a large contributing factor to me wanting a change, I knew that over time if I walked away with the S2 the same may happen again even though it comes packed with duel core processors.
In the end, and after much sitting, staring, fiddling and pondering I went for the HTC Titan. The new OS and unique UI was more than enough to get me to change. In the end it’s only an 18 month contract, not that long right? Oh, wait…
So, which one would you have gone for? Which handset have you got?